Yankee fans. Are you ready? Are you ready for ex manager of the Yankees Joe Torre and the Dodgers? Tell me this isn’t going to be an exciting series. I do think that Joe Torre has lost some of his “aura” because our new manager Joe Girardi won a world series title especially in his second year managing.
Joe Girardi won a title in his second year. The Yankees were title-less for a decade. They were title-less for 9 years when Joe Torre was at the helm.
As we all know, Joe Girardi brings more passion to the game where Joe Torre would sit down during games looking bored. Joe Girardi screams and gets into umpires faces whereas Joe Torre would get in an umpires face but not like Girardi does. Girardi really gets into it. He turns his cap backwards and really gets at an umpire and you see spit juice flying every where.
Joe Torre trusted his veterans more whereas Joe Girardi would use a rookie player before Joe Torre would. If Joe Torre was our manager, do you think Francisco Cervelli would of gotten the chance to be our starting catcher?
Joe Torre took criticism for leaving pitchers in too long but Joe Girard gets criticism for bringing in the wrong pitchers out of the bull pen. I remember watching games with Joe Torre as manager and my family would be saying, “Why is he still in the game?” With Joe Girardi it’s, “Why did you bring HIM in the game?”
Another difference between the managers is the throwing at the other team. If a Yankee player got plunked by an opposing team, Joe Torre didn’t want retaliation. You weren’t allowed to hit the Red Sox player after they hit one of ours. With Joe Girardi, you’re allowed to strike back like the Empire. I would assume that Girardi would “expect” you to hit one of their players if ours got hit.
The best thing about Joe Torre was the stability he brought to the Yankees. You weren’t going to get a new manager every year because he didn’t open his mouth or fight back against George Steinbrenner. He was quiet. With that brought stability to the team with every one knowing they were going to be playing for the same manager every year.
Joe Girardi wouldn’t of survived 15 years of George Steinbrenner. He wouldn’t of survived two years because of his fiery personality. He’s the perfect manager for the Steinbrenner brothers however because the brothers don’t go crazy after a playoff exit.
My take on who’s better? What I just said actually. Torre was the perfect manager for the George years and Girardi is perfect for now.









